Athletic Honors
| NSCAA All-America |
| Andrew Kean (3rd), 1998, (3rd), 1999 |
| Great Lakes Region All-American |
| Tim Brown (3rd), 2002 |
| Jamal Frazier (3rd), 2000 |
| Myron Vaughn (3rd), 2000 |
| All-Mideast |
| Andrew Kean, 1998, 1999 |
| Jake Witkowski, 1999 |
| Mark Schuermann, 1993 |
| Todd Cox, 1991, 1992 |
| Greg Page, 1988, 1990 |
| Tim Henke, 1989 |
| Jeff Miller, 1989 |
| Tim Lesiak, 1989, 1990 |
| Dave DeCarlo, 1987 |
| Tom Eckart, 1986 |
| Paul Jungkunz, 1985 |
| Sam Tilford, 1982, 1983 |
| Craig McDowell, 1981, 1982, 1983 |
| Ted Walters, 1981 |
| Wayne Stuntz, 1979 |
| Mike Whiting, 1978, 1979 |
| Ed Hartman, 1977, 1978 |
| All-Ohio |
| Tim Brown, 2002 |
| Wiremu Patrick, 2002 |
| Shane Curran, 2001 |
| Brandon Dobbs, 2001 |
| Jamal Frazier, 2000 |
| Myron Vaughn, 2000 |
| Andrew Kean, 1998, 1999 |
| Ryan Schreck, 1999 |
| Jake Witkowski, 1999 |
| Johan Cedergren, 1998 |
| Mark Schuermann, 1993 |
| Jason Arszman, 1992 |
| Chris Beerman, 1991 |
| Todd Cox, 1990-92 |
| Greg Legeza, 1991 |
| Tim Henke, 1988, 1989 |
| Dave Kiley, 1989 |
| Jeff Miller, 1989 |
| Tim Lesiak, 1989, 1990 |
| Greg Page, 1988, 1990 |
| Bill Hoelmer, 1988 |
| Dave DeCarlo, 1987 |
| Mike Danyi, 1986 |
| Tom Eckart, 1985, 1986 |
| Paul Jungkunz, 1985, 1986 |
| Sam Tilford, 1982, 1983 |
| Ted Walters, 1981, 1982 |
| Craig McDowell, 1981, 1982, 1983 |
| Micky Dunn, 1981 |
| Roy Bueter, 1979, 1980 |
| Wayne Stuntz, 1979, 1980 |
| Mike Whiting, 1976, 1977, 1978, 1979 |
| Luis Pedraza, 1977 |
| Mike Raita, 1976 |
| Ohio Player of the Year |
| Greg Page, 1990 |
| Andrew Kean, 1999 |
| All-Great Midwest |
| Brian Ruzzo (1st), 1994 |
| Mike Shingleton (2nd), 1994 |
| Mike Riechman, 1993 |
| Jason Arzsman (2nd), 1992 |
| Chris Sphar (2nd), 1992 |
| Chris Beerman (2nd), 1991 |
| Gary Boeres (1st), 1991 |
| Todd Cox (1st), 1991, 1992 |
| Mark Schuermann (1st), 1993; (2nd) 1991 |
| Great Midwest All-Newcomer |
| Mike Mobley, 1994 |
| Sean Endicott, 1993 |
| Billy Hamilton, 1992 |
| All-Big Central |
| Todd Cox (1st), 1990 |
| Rob Scheper (1st), 1990 |
| Tim Henke (2nd), 1989 |
| David Kiley (2nd), 1989 |
| Tim Lesiak (1st), 1989; (2nd) 1990 |
| Greg Page (1st), 1988, 1990 |
| Bill Hoelmer (2nd), 1988 |
| Big Central All-Tournament |
| Todd Cox, 1990 |
| Tim Lesiak, 1990 |
| Greg Page, 1989-90 |
| All-Conference USA |
| Tim Brown (2nd), 2002 |
| Josh Gardner (2nd), 2002 |
| Brandon Dobbs (3rd), 2002 |
| Wiremu Patrick (3rd), 2002 |
| Ryan Schreck (1st), 2000 |
| Myron Vaughn (1st), 2000 |
| Jamal Frazier (2nd), 2000 |
| Andrew Kean (1st), 1999; (2nd), 1998 |
| Ryan Schreck (1st), 1999 |
| Johan Cedergren (3rd), 1999 |
| Jake Witkowski (3rd), 1999; (2nd),1998 |
| Brad Ruzzo (2nd), 1998 |
| Myron Vaughn (3rd), 1998 |
| Mike Mobley (3rd), 1997, 1996 |
| Tim Hamm (2nd), 1996 |
| Billy Hamilton (2nd), 1995 |
| James LaBar (HM), 1995 |
| C-USA Freshman of the Year |
| Kyle Meador, 1998 |
| C-USA Defensive Player of the Year |
| Andrew Kean, 1999 |
| C-USA All Freshman |
| Jarrett Devereaux, 2002 |
| John Liersemann, 2001 |
| Wiremu Patrick, 2001 |
| Sacha Nathu, 2000 |
| Anders Cedergren, 1999 |
| Scott Lyons, 1999 |
| Kyle Meador, 1998 |
| Issiah Davis, 1997 |
| Andrew Kean, 1997 |
| Myron Vaughn, 1997 |
| Greg Ruebusch, 1996 |
Academic Honors
| Verizon Academic All-America |
| Jon Galazka 1998 |
| Mike Shingleton 1994 |
| Verizon Academic All-District IV |
| Anders Cedergren 2002 |
| Matt Hayden 2002 |
| Jon Galazka 1998 |
| Mike Shingleton 1992-94 |
| Keith Kronoveter 1992-93 |
| NSCAA Scholar-Athlete |
| Greg Ruebusch 1998 |
| All-Great Lakes Region |
| Greg Ruebusch 1998, 1999 |
| Mike Shingleton 1992, 1994 |
| All-Ohio |
| Tim Brown 2002 |
| Anders Cedergren 2002 |
| Andrew Kean 1997 |
| Luke Wiley 1995-96 |
| Tim Henke 1989 |
| Andy Krueger 1989 |
| Dave DeCarlo 1987 |
| Tom Eckart 1985-86 |
| Paul Maurer 1981 |
| Cincinnati Scholar-Athlete of the Year |
| Derek Moore, 2002 |
| Conference USA Commissioner's Academic Medal |
| Anders Cedergren 2000-03 |
| Derek Moore 2001-02 |
| Matt Hayden 2002 |
| C-USA Scholar-Athlete of the Year |
| Ryan Schreck 2001 |
| C-USA Commissioner's Honor Roll |
| Anders Cedergren 2000-03 |
| John Adams 2000-03 |
| Tim Brown 2001-03 |
| Justin Dobbs 2002-03 |
| Matt Hayden 2002-03 |
| Eric Edwards 2003 |
| Mike Vessells 2003 |
| Josh Gardner 2002 |
| Derek Moore 2001-02 |
| Andy Barton 2000 |
| Johan Cedergren 1998, 2000 |
| Scott Connor 1996-97 |
| Curtis Cyran 1995 |
| Ben Czajka 1995 |
| Paul Davidson 1997, 1999 |
| Adam Dobrozsi 1996-98 |
| Jon Galazka 1998-2000 |
| Nick Goodwin 1995 |
| Craig Hauzie 1995 |
| Andrew Kean 1999 |
| Mike Mobley 1997 |
| Greg Ruebusch 1997-99 |
| Adam Schauer 2000 |
| Ryan Schreck 2000 |
| David Sekorky 1995-97 |
| Chris Vehr 1996, 1997 |
| Shaun Whitehead 1996 |
| Luke Wiley 1995, 1996 |
| Great Midwest Medal of Honor |
| Keith Kronoveter 1991-93 |
| GMC Commissioner's List |
| Curtis Cyran 1994 |
| Luke Wiley 1994 |
| Keith Spinola 1993-94 |
| Jeff Hajek 1991-94 |
| Mike Shingleton 1991-94 |
| Matteo Mancini 1993 |
| Mike Riechman 1992 |
| Jim Townhill 1992-93 |
| Keith Kronoveter 1991-93 |
| Jason Arszman 1991-92 |
| Todd Cox 1991 |
| Jay Schneider 1991 |