| All-American |
| 1961 |
Bill Faul (1st) |
| 1962 |
Bill Faul (3rd) |
| 1965 |
Billy Wolff (1st) |
| 1967 |
Pat Maginn (2nd) |
| 1974 |
Tim Burman (HM) |
| 1996 |
Steve Barhorst (HM) |
| 2000 |
Kevin Youkilis (2nd) |
| 2001 |
Kevin Youkilis (2nd, 3rd) |
| 2008 |
Josh Harrison (2nd) |
| |
| Freshman All-American |
| 1999 |
Chris Hamblen |
| 2001 |
Tony Maynard |
| 2002 |
Kyle Markle |
| 2006 |
Steve Blevins |
| |
Josh Harrison |
| 2010 |
Andrew Strenge |
| 2011 |
Justin Glass |
| |
| ABCA All-Region |
| 2001 |
Chris Hamblen |
| |
Kevin Youkilis |
| 2002 |
Chris Hamblen |
| 2007 |
Dan Osterbrock (1st) |
| |
Tony Campana (2nd) |
| |
Josh Harrison (2nd) |
| |
| Johnny Bench Award Finalist |
| 2001 |
Chris Hamblen |
| |
| Johnny Bench Award Semifinalist |
| 2002 |
Chris Hamblen |
| |
| Baseball Weekly National Player of the Week |
| 2002 |
Joe List |
| |
| CoSIDA Academic All-America |
| 2001 |
Craig Tewes (2nd) |
| 2006 |
Jack Nelson (3rd) |
| |
| CoSIDA Academic All-District |
| 2001 |
Craig Tewes |
| 2004 |
Jack Nelson (1st) |
| 2005 |
Mark Muscenti (2nd) |
| 2006 |
Jack Nelson (1st) |
| |
Mark Muscenti (2nd) |
| |
| Conference USA Scholar Athlete of the Year |
| 2001 |
Matt Singer |
| |
| Jimmy Nippert Award |
| 1986 |
Bob Heheman |
| 2001 |
Matt Singer |
| |
| BIG EAST Player of the Year |
| 2008 |
Josh Harrison |
| |
| All-BIG EAST |
| 2006 |
Steve Blevins (2nd) |
| |
Josh Harrison (3rd) |
| |
Logan Parker (3rd) |
| 2007 |
Dan Osterbrock (1st) |
| |
Tony Campana (2nd) |
| |
Neall French (2nd) |
| |
Josh Harrison (2nd) |
| 2008 |
Tony Campana (1st) |
| |
Josh Harrison (1st) |
| |
Dan Osterbrock (2nd) |
| |
Mike Spina (2nd) |
| |
Ryan Baker (3rd) |
| |
Cameron Satterwhite (3rd) |
| 2009 |
Lance Durham (2nd) |
|
Mike Spina (2nd) |
| 2010 |
Andrew Burkett (3rd) |
|
Brian Garman (3rd) |
|
Jimmy Jacquot (3rd) |
| 2011 |
Justin Riddell (1st) |
|
Justin Glass (2nd) |
|
Braden Kline (3rd) |
| |
| BIG EAST Player of the Week |
| 2006 |
Steve Blevins (Pitcher)-twice |
| |
Jon DeLuca (Hitter) |
| |
Logan Parker (Hitter) |
| |
Glen Simon (Pitcher) |
| 2007 |
Steve Blevins (Pitcher) |
| |
Tony Campana (Hitter) |
| |
Dan Osterbrock (Pitcher) |
| 2008 |
Tony Campana (Hitter) |
| |
Josh Harrison (Hitter) |
| |
Michael Hill (Pitcher) |
| |
Dan Osterbrock (Pitcher) |
| |
Mike Spina (Hitter) |
| 2009 |
T.J. Jones (Hitter) |
| 2010 |
Jimmy Jaquot (Hitter) |
|
Andrew Strenge (Pitcher) |
| 2011 |
Dan Jensen (Pitcher) |
| |
| BIG EAST All-Championship Team |
| 2008 |
Ryan Baker |
| |
Josh Harrison |
| |
Jamel Scott |
| |
Mike Spina |
|
| Conference USA All-Decade Team |
| 2004 |
Kevin Youkilis |
| |
| All-Conference USA |
| 1996 |
Steve Barhorst (2nd) |
| |
Jerry Merrill (HM) |
| 1997 |
John Carney (3rd) |
| 1999 |
Matt Singer (1st) |
| |
Anthony Snowell (2nd) |
| |
Craig Tewes (2nd) |
| |
Kevin Youkilis (2nd) |
| 2000 |
Matt Singer (1st) |
| |
Kevin Youkilis (1st) |
| |
Curtus Moak (2nd) |
| 2001 |
Chris Hamblen (1st) |
| |
Matt Singer (1st) |
| |
Kevin Youkilis (1st) |
| |
Brett Clark (2nd) |
| |
Curtus Moak (2nd) |
| |
Craig Tewes (2nd) |
| 2002 |
Joe List (1st) |
| |
Brad Schutz (1st) |
| |
Chris Hamblen (2nd) |
| 2004 |
Steve Pickerell (2nd) |
| |
| C-USA All-Freshman |
| 1996 |
Corey Hinton |
| 1998 |
Matt Singer |
| |
Craig Tewes |
| 1999 |
Chris Hamblen |
| 2001 |
Tony Maynard |
| |
| C-USA All-Tournament |
| 2000 |
Curtus Moak |
| |
Brad Schutz |
| |
Matt Singer |
| |
Craig Tewes |
| |
| C-USA Academic Medal |
| 1996 |
Bill Jung |
| 1998 |
Bill Jung |
| 2002 |
Mark Muscenti |
| |
Jim Olds |
| 2003 |
Mark Muscenti |
| |
Jim Olds |
| 2004 |
Jim Olds |
| 2005 |
Dustin Alvey |
| |
Jim Olds |
|
| C-USA Player of the Week |
| 1998 |
Matt Singer (Hitter) |
| |
Craig Tewes (Hitter) |
| 1999 |
Joe List (Pitcher) |
| |
Anthony Snowell (Hitter) |
| |
Craig Tewes (Hitter) |
| 2000 |
Kevin Youkilis (Hitter) |
| 2001 |
B.J. Borsa (Pitcher) |
| |
Chris Hamblen (Hitter) |
| |
Kevin Youkilis (Hitter) |
| 2002 |
Brad Dorrmann (Hitter) |
| |
Nate Fish (Hitter) |
| 2003 |
Nate Bouldin (Pitcher) |
| 2005 |
Jon DeLuca (Hitter) |
| |
Logan Parker (Hitter) |
| |
| All-Great Midwest |
| 1992 |
Jamie Baker (1st) |
| |
Todd Cox (2nd) |
| |
Bill Metzinger (2nd) |
| |
Bob Meyer (2nd) |
| |
Troy Muckerheide (2nd) |
| |
Chris Newton (2nd) |
| 1993 |
Mark Gabbard (1st) |
| |
Todd Cox (2nd) |
| |
Bob Meyer (2nd) |
| |
Troy Muckerheide (2nd) |
| |
Steve Spille (2nd) |
| 1994 |
Steve Sloan (2nd) |
| 1995 |
Steve Barhorst (1st) |
| |
Chris Holt (1st) |
| |
Shannon Morgan (1st) |
| |
Troy Muckerheide (1st) |
| |
Matt Primack (1st) |
| |
Jerry Merrill (2nd) |
| |
Chris Murphy (2nd) |
| |
Steve Sloan (2nd) |
| |
| Great Midwest Most Valuable Player |
| 1995 |
Chris Holt |
| |
| Great Midwest All-Tournament |
| 1992 |
Jamie Baker |
| |
Chad DiSalle |
| |
Chris Newton |
| 1994 |
Matt Primack |
| |
| All-Metro |
| 1980 |
Jim Braun |
| |
Jack Kuzniczci |
| |
Darryl Harris |
| 1983 |
Lalo Berezo |
| 1986 |
Pat Abbatiello |
| |
Mike Kinnett |
| 1987 |
Pat Abbatiello |
| |
Mark Martin |
| |
John Young |
| 1988 |
Judd Johnson |
| |
Todd Seymour |
| 1989 |
Tony Elsbrock |
| 1990 |
Jamie Baker |
| |
Tony Elsbrock |
| 1991 |
Mike Mottice |
| |
Ken Schnieder |
| |
| Metro All-Tournament |
| 1987 |
Kerry Byrne |
| |
Mike Kinnett |
| |
John Young |
| 1990 |
Dave Abbott |
| |
Mike Mottice |
| 1991 |
Dave Abbott |
