Newcomer of the Year Award

2005 Dustin Grutza (Off.)
  Trevor Anderson (Def.)
  Terrill Byrd (Def.)
  Mike Mickens (Def.)
2004 Earnest Jackson (Off.)
  Anthony Hoke (Def.)
2003 Hannibal Thomas (Off.)
  Mike Wright (Def.)
2002 Trent Cole (Def.)
  Travis McGee (Off.)
2001 Gino Guidugli (Off.)
  Doug Monaghan (Def.)
2000 Shawn Murphy (Off.)
  Zach Norton (Def.)
1999 Josh Gardner (Off.)
  Ivan Fields (Def.)
1998 DeMarco McCleskey (Off.)
  Blue Adams (Def.)
1997 Jason Collins-Baker (Off.)
  DeJuan Gossett (Def.)
1996 Robert Cooper
1995 Chad Plummer (Off.)
  Orlando Smith (Off.)
1994 Jason Fabini (Off.)
  Philip Curry (Def.)
1993 Chris Hewitt
1992 Jamie Lemire
1991 Reggie Hudson
1990 Paul Anderson (Offense)
  Nate Dingle (Defense)