Newcomer of the Year Award
| 2005 |
Dustin Grutza (Off.) |
| |
Trevor Anderson (Def.) |
| |
Terrill Byrd (Def.) |
| |
Mike Mickens (Def.) |
| 2004 |
Earnest Jackson (Off.) |
| |
Anthony Hoke (Def.) |
| 2003 |
Hannibal Thomas (Off.) |
| |
Mike Wright (Def.) |
| 2002 |
Trent Cole (Def.) |
| |
Travis McGee (Off.) |
| 2001 |
Gino Guidugli (Off.) |
| |
Doug Monaghan (Def.) |
| 2000 |
Shawn Murphy (Off.) |
| |
Zach Norton (Def.) |
| 1999 |
Josh Gardner (Off.) |
| |
Ivan Fields (Def.) |
| 1998 |
DeMarco McCleskey (Off.) |
| |
Blue Adams (Def.) |
| 1997 |
Jason Collins-Baker (Off.) |
| |
DeJuan Gossett (Def.) |
| 1996 |
Robert Cooper |
| 1995 |
Chad Plummer (Off.) |
| |
Orlando Smith (Off.) |
| 1994 |
Jason Fabini (Off.) |
| |
Philip Curry (Def.) |
| 1993 |
Chris Hewitt |
| 1992 |
Jamie Lemire |
| 1991 |
Reggie Hudson |
| 1990 |
Paul Anderson (Offense) |
| |
Nate Dingle (Defense) |
